Principal Problems of Energy Storage Optimization Allocation

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000－7229.2016.09.010

Abstract

Abstract: Energy storage optimization allocation is the foundation of energy storage system （ESS） application, which involves two dimensions of technical and economic aspects, also relates to the different needs of multi-application time scales and power energy. According to the different application requirements of ESS in power grids, focusing on security and stability, frequency regulation, acceptance of renewable energy sources and power quality, this paper analyzes the optimal allocation of its objectives, conditions, methods and theories deeply. Based on the cost-benefit analysis of energy storage system, this paper establishes a general NPV （net present value） optimization model. Combined with the application characteristics of different energy storage, this paper analyzes the selection principles of energy storage type, as well as the combination type of composite energy storage and the methods of capacity allocation. This paper presents the relevant evaluation index and methods for the evaluation of energy storage application from the compensation effect, safety, reliability, economy and so on. Finally, this paper proposes the future research topics in the practice of energy storage planning.

Key words: energy storage, electric power system, optimization allocation, evaluation index

CLC Number:

TM 910

LI Dandan, SU Xiaolin, YAN Xiaoxia, TAN Yixue. Principal Problems of Energy Storage Optimization Allocation[J]. Electric Power Construction, 2016, 37(9): 70-.

References

［1］张文亮，丘明，来小康.储能技术在电力系统中的应用［J］.电网技术，2008，32（7）：1-9. ZHANG Wenliang，QIU Ming，LAI Xiaokang.Application of energy storage technologies in power grids［J］.Power System Technology，2008，32（7）：1-9. ［2］周林，黄勇，郭珂，等.微电网储能技术研究综述［J］.电力系统保护与控制，2011，39（7）：147-152. ZHOU Lin，HUANG Yong，GUO Ke，et al.A survey of energy storage technology for micro grid［J］.Power System Protection and Control，2011，39（7）：147-152. ［3］RIBEIRO P F，JOHNSON B K，CROW M L，et al.Energy storage systems for advanced power applications［J］.Proceedings of the IEEE，2001，89（12）:1744-1756. ［4］赵静波，雷金勇，甘德强.电池储能装置在抑制电力系统低频振荡中的应用［J］.电网技术，2008，32（6）：93-99，108. ZHAO Jingbo，LEI Jinyong，GAN Deqiang.Application of battery energy storage devices in suppressing low-frequency oscillation of power system［J］.Power System Technology，2008，32（6）：93-99，108. ［5］马腾宇.超导储能装置（SMES）用于改善电力系统稳定性的布局研究［D］.武汉：华中科技大学，2009. MA Tengyu.Study on the optimal location of Superconducting Magnetic energy storage （SMES） used for improving the transient stability of Power System ［D］.Wuhan：Huazhong University of Science and Technology，2009. ［6］LIU D B， SHIL J， XU Q，et al.Selection of installing locations of flywheel energy storage system in multi-machine power systems by modal analysis［C］//International Conference on Sustainable Power Generation and Supply.Nanjing，China:IEEE，2009. ［7］UEDA S，TAKEUCHI H，OHSAWA Y. Studies on power system stabilization by distributed allocation of micro SMES units［C］//Proceedings of IEEE Conference on Power System Technology.Kunming，China:IEEE，2002. ［8］LI Y Z，WADA K，OHSAWA Y. Optimal allocation of micro SMES units for power system stabilization by means of genetic algorithm［C］//Proceedings of IEEE Conference on Power System Technology.Chongqing，China:IEEE，2006. ［9］夏亚君.储能提高电力系统暂态稳定性的优化配置研究［D］.武汉：华中科技大学，2012. XIA Yajun.The optimal allocation of energy storage system for enhancing transient stability of power system ［D］.Wuhan：Huazhong University of Science and Technology，2012. ［10］吴迪，刘世林，文劲宇.一种基于暂态稳定风险的储能位置与容量优化方法［J］.电力科学与技术学报，2012，27（1）：19-26. WU Di，LIU Shilin，WEN Jinyu.A transient stability risk assessment based optimization method［J］.Journal of Electric Power Science and Technology，2012，27（1）：19-26. ［11］OHSAWA Y，MARUOKA Y，TAKENO H，et al.Determination of installation location of SMES for power system stabilization［C］//Proceedings of IEEE Conference on Circuits and Systems.Geneva，Switzerland:IEEE，2000. ［12］熊雄，袁铁江，杨水丽，等.基于电压稳定与限值的风/储系统容量配置［J］.电网与清洁能源，2012，28（4）：63-68. XIONG Xiong，YUAN Tiejiang，YANG Shuili，et al.Based on the voltage stability and limit wind-energy storage system capacity configuration［J］.Power System and Clean Energy，2012，28（4）：63-68. ［13］李婷婷.需求侧储能提高电网静态安全性的优化配置研究［D］.武汉：华中科技大学，2013. LI Tingting.Optimal configuration of demand side ES for improving the power system Security［D］.Wuhan：Huazhong University of Science and Technology，2013. ［14］李红梅，严正.用可再生能源充电的SMES装置在系统调频中的应用［J］.电力系统自动化，2009，33（15）：94-97,102. LI Hongmei，YAN Zheng.Application of renewable energy charged SMES devices in power system frequency regulation［J］.Automation of Electric Power Systems，2009，33（15）：94-97,102. ［15］MERCIER P，CHERKAOUI R，OUDALOV A.Optimizing a battery energy storage system for frequency control application in an isolated power system［J］.IEEE Transactions on Power Systems，2009，24（3），1469-1477. ［16］ALEXANDRE O，DANIEL C，CHRISTIAN O.Optimizing a battery energy storage system for primary frequency control［J］.IEEE Transactions on Power Systems，2007，22（3）:1259-1266. ［17］丁冬.适用于调频的储能系统配置策略研究［D］.北京：华北电力大学，2015. DING Dong.Research on energy storage system configuration strategy for frequency regulation ［D］.Beijing：North China Electric Power University，2015. ［18］黄际元，李欣然，曹一家，等.考虑储能参与快速调频动作时机与深度的容量配置方法［J］.电工技术学报，2015，30（12）：454-464. HUANG Jiyuan，LI Xiran，CAO Yijia，et al.Capacity allocation of energy storage system considering its action moment and output depth in rapid frequency regulation［J］.Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society，2015，30（12）：454-464. ［19］姜书鹏，乔颖，徐飞，等.风储联合发电系统容量优化配置模型及敏感性分析［J］.电力系统自动化，2013，37（20）：16-21. JIANG Shupeng，QIAO Ying，XU Fei，et al.Capacity optimization and sensitivity analysis of cogeneration system of wind power and energy storage［J］.Automation of Electric Power Systems，2013，37（20）：16-21. ［20］冯江霞，梁军，张峰，等.考虑调度计划和运行经济性的风电场储能容量优化计算［J］.电力系统自动化，2013，37（1）：90-95. FENG Jiangxia，LIANG Jun，ZHANG Feng，et al.An optimization calculation method of wind farm energy storage capacity［J］.Automation of Electric Power Systems，2013，37（1）：90-95. ［21］GUPTA A，SAINIR P, SHARMAM P.Hybrid energy system sizing incorporating battery storage: an analysis via simulation calculation［C］//Proceedings of IEEE Conference on Power System.Kharagpur，Indian:IEEE，2009. ［22］杨水丽，惠东，李建林，等.适用于风电场的最佳电池容量选取的方法［J］.电力建设，2010，31（9）：1-4. YANG Shuili，HUI Dong，LI Jianlin，et al.Selection of the optimal battery capacity for wind farm［J］.Electric Power Construction，2010，31（9）：1-4. ［23］张浩，马爱军，李文斌，等.风电场日出力曲线和储能容量关系研究［J］.中国电力，2012，45（6）：77-81. ZHANG Hao，MA Aijun，LI Wenbin，et al.Research of the relationship between wind farm output and energy storage［J］.Electric Power，2012，45（6）：77-81. ［24］韩涛，卢继平，乔梁，等.大型并网风电场储能容量优化方案［J］.电网技术，2010，34（1）：169-173. HAN Tao，LU Jiping，QIAO Liang，et al.Optimized scheme of energy storage capacity for grid-connected large-scale wind farm［J］.Power System Technology，2010，34（1）：169-173. ［25］毛彪.液流储能对分布式发电系统稳定运行的作用机理及优化配置理论研究［D］.武汉：华中科技大学，2012. MAO Biao.Research on mechanism and optimization theory of the impact of VRB energy storage on stable operation of distributed generation system［D］.Wuhan：Huazhong University of Science and Technology，2012. ［26］刘小寨，徐天，葛立坤，等.含风电场的电网储能系统选址和优化配置［J］.电网与清洁能源，2014，30（12）：119-125. LIU Xiaozhai，XU Tian，GE Likun，et al.Location selection and optimal allocation for energy storage system of power system with wind farm［J］.Power System and Clean Energy，2012，30（12）：119-125. ［27］李翔.抑制风电电压闪变的混合储能优化配置方法［D］.广州：华南理工大学，2013. LI Xiang. Hybrid energy storage systems for wind power systems: optimization of system capacity and cost through suppress voltage flicker［D］.Guangzhou：South China University of Technology，2013. ［28］颜志敏，王承民，连鸿波，等.计及缺电成本的用户侧蓄电池储能系统容量规划［J］.电力系统自动化，2012，36（11）：50-54. YAN Zhimin，WANG Chengmin，LIAN Hongbo，et al.Capacity plan of battery energy storage system in user side considering power outtage cost［J］.Automation of Electric Power Systems，2012，36（11）：50-54. ［29］向育鹏，卫志农，孙国强，等.基于全寿命周期成本的配电网蓄电池储能系统的优化配置［J］.电网技术，2015，39（1）：264-270. XIANG Yupeng，WEI Zhinong，SUN Guoqiang，et al.Life cycle cost based optimal configuration of battery energy storage system indistribution network［J］.Power System Technology，2015，39（1）：264-270. ［30］肖峻，张泽群，张磐，等.用于优化微网联络线功率的混合储能容量优化方法［J］.电力系统自动化，2014，38（12）：19-26. XIAO Jun，ZHANG Zequn，ZHANG Pan，et al.A capacity optimization method of hybrid energy storage system for optimizing tie-line power in microgrids［J］.Automation of Electric Power Systems，2014，38（12）：19-26. ［31］殷志敏，晁勤，王一波，等.波动率优于国网标准的风电场储能容量经济优化配置［J］.可再生能源，2016，32（1）：86-94. YIN Zhimin，CHAO Qin，WANG Yibo，et al.An economic optimal method for wind farm energy storage capacity with superior fluctuation rate to standard of the State Grid［J］.Renewable Energy Resources，2016，32（1）：86-94. ［32］谢石骁，杨莉，李丽娜.基于机会约束规划的混合储能优化配置方法［J］.电网技术，2012，36（5）：79-84. XIE Shixiao，YANG Li，LI Lina.A chanceconstrained programming based optimal configuration method of hybrid energy storage system［J］.Power System Technology，2012，36（5）：79-84 ［33］黎静华，文劲宇，程时杰，等.基于p-有效点理论的含大规模风电电力系统最小储能功率配置方法［J］.中国电机工程学报，2013，33（13）：45-52. LI Jinghua，WEN Jinyu，CHENG Shijie，et al.Method of minimum energy storage power allocation for electric power systems with large-scale wind power based on p-efficient point theory［J］.Proceedings of the CSEE，2013，33（13）：45-52. ［34］HIDA Y，ITO Y，YOKOYAMA R, et al.A study of optimal capacity of PV and battery energy storage system distributed in demand side［C］//Universities Power Engineering Conference （UPEC）. Cardiff，Wales:IEEE，2010. ［35］张峰，董晓明，梁军，等.考虑目标分解及其互补平抑的风电场复合储能容量优化［J］.电力系统自动化，2014，38（7）：9-15. ZHANG Feng，DONG Xiaoming，LIANG Jun，et al.Capacity optimization of hybrid energy storage system based on target decomposition and complementary fluctuations smothing［J］.Automation of Electric Power Systems，2014，38（7）：9-15. ［36］李成，杨秀，张美霞，等.基于成本分析的超级电容器和蓄电池混合储能优化配置方案［J］.电力系统自动化，2013，37（18）：20-24. LI Cheng，YANG Xiu，ZHANG Meixia，et al.Optimal configuration scheme for hybrid energy storage system of super—capacitors and batteries based on cost analysis［J］.Automation of Electric Power Systems，2013，37（18）：20-24. ［37］马速良，蒋小平，马会萌，等.平抑风电波动的混合储能系统的容量配置［J］.电力系统保护与控制，2014，42（8）：108-114. MA Suliang，JIANG Xiaoping，MA Huimeng，et al.Capacity configuration of the hybrid energy storage system for wind power smoothing［J］.Power System Protection and Control，2014，42（8）：108-114. ［38］熊雄，叶林，杨仁刚，等.多元复合储能在独立微电网中运行策略及容量优化研究［J］.智能电网，2014，2（6）：5-10. XIONG Xiong，YE Lin，YANG Rengang，et al.Operation strategy and capacity optimization of multi-element composite energy storage system in stand-alone microgrid［J］.Smart Grid，2014，2（6）：5-10. ［39］高孝天，凌志斌，郭海峰，等.基于粒子群优化的风储配合控制策略研究［J］.太阳能学报，2014，35（11）：2249-2256. GAO Xiaotian，LING Zhibin，GUO Haifeng，et al.Control strategies for wind farm with battery energy storage based on particle swarm optimization［J］.Acta Energiae Solaris Sinica，2014，35（11）：2249-2256. ［40］ZHONG Qing，YU Nanhua，ZHANG Xiaoping，et al.Optimal siting＆sizing of battery energy storage system in active distribution network［C］//IEEE/PES Innovation Smart Grid Technologies Europe. Lyngby，Denmark:IEEE，2013. ［41］瞿海妮，刘建清.国内外配电网供电可靠性指标比较分析［J］.华东电力，2012，40（9）：1566-1570. QU Haini，LIU Jianqin.Comparison and analysis on power supply reliability indicators of distribution network at home and abroad［J］.East China Electric Power，2012，40（9）：1566-1570. ［42］谭兴国，王辉，张黎，等.微电网复合储能多目标优化配置方法及评价指标［J］.电力系统自动化，2014，32（8）：7-14. TAN Xingguo，WANG Hui，ZHANG Li，et al.Multi-objective optimization of hybrid energy storage and assessment indices in microgrid［J］.Automation of Electric Power Systems，2014，32（8）：7-14. ［43］杨毅，刘洁，于建成，等.分布式储能优化配置影响因素的评价方法研究［J］.现代电子技术，2015，38（2）：152-157. YANG Yi，LIU Jie，YU Jiancheng，et al.Evaluation method of distributed energy storage system in consideration of optimizationconfiguration influence factors［J］.Modern Electronics Technique，2015，38（2）：152-157.

[1]	ZHU Xu, YANG Jun, LI Gaojunjie, DONG Xuzhu, LIU Shouwen. Optimal Dispatching Strategy of Regional Integrated Energy System Considering Virtual Energy Storage System朱旭1，杨军1，李高俊杰1，董旭柱1，刘首文2 [J]. ELECTRIC POWER CONSTRUCTION, 2020, 41(8): 99-110.
[2]	JIANG Dajun， WU Fubao， WANG Qiyun， ZHANG Yanjun， SUN Lixia， WU Yingjun. Robust Optimal Combined Wind-Storage Scheduling Based on Regulatory Cloud [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(7): 9-16.
[3]	FANG Chaoxiong， WU Xiaosheng， JIANG Yuewen. Research on Multi-Objective Bi-Level Optimization of Network-Storage Considering Transient Stability [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(7): 58-66.
[4]	ZHANG Kai， QIU Xiaoyan， LI Linghao， ZHANG Haoyu， ZHAO Youlin， LIU Mengyi. Energy Storage Configuration Scheme Considering the Effect of Static Voltage Stability in Wind Power Systems [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(7): 110-116.
[5]	JIA Xuecui 1， LI Xiangjun 1， WAN Jun 2， LI Wenqi3， HUO Fangqiang2. Control Method of Large-Scale Battery Energy Storage System for Suppressing the Disturbance of Power Grid [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(6): 69-76.
[6]	LI Jianlin， LI Yaxin，ZHOU Xichao. Summary of Research on Grid-Side Energy Storage Technology [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(6): 77-84.
[7]	SU Junni，ZHANG Xin，ZHAO Junwei，ZHANG Rui，QU Minghui，YANG Yanhong. Optimal Dispatching of Integrated Electricity-Gas System Considering Demand Response and Energy Storage [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(5): 1-8.
[8]	ZHANG Zhirong， QIU Xiaoyan， SUN Xu， REN Hao， ZHANG Mingke. Economic Optimal Scheduling of AC/DC Distribution Network Coordinating Flexible Load and Energy Storage Systems#br# [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(5): 116-123.
[9]	DONG Ling， NIAN Heng， FAN Yue， ZHAO Jianyong， ZHANG Zhi，LIN Zhenzhi. Exploration and Practice of Business Model of Shared Energy Storage in Energy Internet [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(4): 38-44.
[10]	GUO Wei，XIU Xiaoqing，LI Wenqi，LI Jianlin. Siting and Configuration Methods for Grid-Side Energy Storage System Considering Multi-Attribute Comprehensive Indices and Economy [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(4): 53-62.
[11]	LIU Lu， NIU Meng， LI Jianlin，HUI Dong. Research on Status and Architecture of Standards on Electrochemical Energy Storage System [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(4): 63-72.
[12]	FU Jianmin, YANG Bin, WANG Xiaojun, SUN Qingkai, ZHANG Yizhi, HE Jinghan, ZHANG Fang. Planning of Integrated Energy System for High-Speed Railway Station Considering Energy Storage of Buildings [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(3): 13-22.
[13]	SHI Jingjian， ZHOU Wentao， ZHANG Ning， CHEN Qiao， LIU Jintao，CAO Zhenbo， CHEN Yi， SONG Hang， LIU Youbo. Deep Reinforcement Learning Algorithm of Voltage Regulation in Distribution Network with Energy Storage System [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(3): 71-78.
[14]	REN Junzhi， CHEN Jian， JIANG Xinyi， SUN Xuri， ZHANG Song， LI Wensheng. Post-Disaster Recovery Strategy of Resilient Distribution Network Considering Mobile Energy Storage System and Network Reconfiguration [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(3): 86-92.
[15]	LIAO Hongtu， HUANG Yihong， SHI Yizhi， CHEN Jian. A Bi-Level Two-Stage Robust Optimal Operation Strategy for AC and DC Distribution Network with Photovoltaic and Energy Storage [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(3): 110-118.