Comparison and Analysis of Multi-Attribute and Multi-Objective Energy Storage System Working Conditions Suitability

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000－7229.2018.04.001

Abstract

Abstract: ABSTRACT： There are different technical requirements for energy storage in power generation, transmission and other sectors. There are obvious technical and economic differences between energy storage types. There is no standardized evaluation index for energy storage configuration options that are suitable for different operating conditions. From the view of energy storage selection, this paper presents a comparative analysis method for the applicability of multi-attribute and multi-objective energy storage conditions. Based on the capacity allocation, investment cost and technical applicability of different energy storage types, we proposes the comprehensive evaluation index of energy storage conditions applicability comparison. And according to different demands of the power generation side, transmission side and the source network contradictory in power system, we establish the energy storage capacity optimization configuration method based on the characteristics of different types of energy storage technologies, in order to obtain the optimal energy storage scheme under different application scenarios. Finally, through the example analysis, the validity of the proposes method and the rationality of index selection are verified, which can provide the research foundation for the development of related energy storage technology.

Key words: wind power, energy storage configuration, smooth fluctuations, wind power transmission, peak regulation and frequency modulation

CLC Number:

LI Junhui1, ZHANG Jiahui1, Hu Dacheng1, LI Jianlin2, MA Huimeng2. Comparison and Analysis of Multi-Attribute and Multi-Objective Energy Storage System Working Conditions Suitability[J]. Electric Power Construction, 2018, 39(4): 2-.

References

［1］国家能源局.前三季度全国风电新增并网970万千瓦弃风率下降36.7%.［2017-11-06］.http://www.nea,gov.cn/2017/11/03/c_136725791.htm.

［2］刘波，贺志佳，金昊.风力发电现状与发展趋势［J］.东北电力大学学报，2016，36（2）：7-13.

LIU Bo，HE Zhijia，JIN Hao.Wind power status and development trends［J］.Journal of Northeast Electric Power University，2016，36（2）：7-13.

［3］舒印彪，张智刚，郭剑波，等.新能源消纳关键因素分析及解决措施研究［J］.中国电机工程学报，2017，37（1）：1-9.

SHU Yinbiao，ZHANG Zhigang，GUO Jianbo，et al.Study on key factors and solution of renewable energy accommodation ［J］ .Proceedings of the CSEE，2017，37（1）：1-9.

［4］李强，袁越，谈定中.储能技术在风电并网中的应用研究进展［J］.河海大学学报（自然科学版），2010，38（1）：115-122.

LI Qiang，YUAN Yue，DAN Dingzhong.Application and research progress of energy storage technology in wind power grid integration［J］.Journal of Hohai University（Natural Sciences），2010，38（1）：115-122.

［5］程时杰，余文辉，文劲宇，等.储能技术及其在电力系统稳定控制中的应用［J］.电网技术，2007，31（20）：97-108.

CHEN Shijie，YU Wenhui，WEN Jingyu，et al.Energy storage and its application in power system stability enhancement［J］.Power System Technology，2007，31（20）：97-108.

［6］俞恩科，陈梁金.大规模电力储能技术的特性与比较［J］.浙江电力，2011，30（12）：4-8.

YU Enke，CHEN Liangjin.Characteristics and comparison of large-scale electric energy storage technologies［J］.Zhenjiang Electric Power，2011，30（12）：4-8.

［7］吴贤章，尚晓丽.可再生能源发电及智能电网储能技术比较［J］.储能科学与技术，2013，2（3）：316-320.

WU Xianzhang，SHANG Xiaoli.A review of electrical energy storage technologies for renewable power generation and smart grids［J］.Energy Storage Science and Technology，2013，2（3）：316-320.

［8］ MACIEJ S，DANIEL I S，ANA-IRINA S，et al.Selection and performance-degradation modeling of LiMO2/Li4Ti5O12 and LiFePO4/C battery cells as suitable energy storage systems for grid integration with wind power plants: An example for the primary frequency regulation service［J］.IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy，2014，5（1）：90-101.

［9］ ARTHUR K B，JUAN C B，SCOTT O G，et al.Optimal battery chemistry，capacity selection，charge/discharge schedule，and lifetime of energy storage under time-of-use pricing［C］// 2011 2nd IEEE PES International Conference and Exhibition on Innovative Smart Grid Technologies. Manchester： IEEE，2011：1-7.

［10］ ALEXANDER B，LUCIANE N C，ALZENIRADA R A，et al.Selection of storage energy technologies in a power quality scenario-the AHP and the fuzzy logic［C］// 35th Annual Conference of IEEE Industrial Electronics. Porto：IEEE，2009：3615-3620.

［11］李军徽，蒋莲，李翠萍，等.用于超级电容器储能系统变流器的控制策略设计［J］.东北电力大学学报，2017，37（4）：32-38.

LI Junhui，JIANG Lian，LI Cuiping，et al.Control strategy designed for converter of super capacitor energy storage system［J］.Journal of Northeast Electric Power University，2017，37（4）：32-38.

［12］赵波，张雪松，李鹏，等.储能系统在东福山岛独立型微电网中的优化设计和应用［J］.电力系统自动化，2013，37（1）：161-167.

ZHAO Bo，ZHANG Xuesong，LI Peng，et al.Optimum design and application of energy storage system in Dongfu island independent microgrid［J］ .Automation of Electric Power Systems，2013，37（1）：161-167.

［13］王成山，于波，肖峻，等.平滑可再生能源发电系统输出波动的储能系统容量优化方法［J］.中国电机工程学报，2012，32（16）：1-8.

WANG Chengshan，YU Bo，XIAO Jun，et al.Sizing of energy storage systems for output smoothing of renewable energy systems［J］.Proceedings of the CSEE，2012，32（16）：1-8.

［14］ ZHU Y，WANG T，TIAN J.Means selection and capacity configuration of energy storage［C］//2009 International Conference on Sustainable Power Generation and Supply. Nanjing：IEEE，2009：1-4.

［15］杜兆斌，邓桂萍，席云华，等.大型移动保供电电源储能元件选型分析［J］.机电工程技术，2013，42（9）：47-50，102.

DU Zhaobin，DENG Guiping，XI Yunhua，et al.Selection of energy-storage battery of mobile large-capacity power source for power supply ensuring of users［J］.Mechanical and Electrical Engineering Technology，2013，42（9）：47-50，102.

［16］ SHELDON S W，ALIREZA K，SUNG C O，et al.Impact of energy storage device selection on the overall drive train efficiency and performance of heavy-duty hybrid vehicles［C］//2005 IEEE Vehicle Power and Propulsion Conference. Chicago：IEEE，2005：381-390.

［17］李翠萍，曹璞佳，李军徽，等.大规模分布式光伏并网无功电压控制方法综述［J］.东北电力大学学报，2017，37（2）：82-88.

LI Cuiping，CAO Pujia，LI Junhui，et al.Review on reactive voltage control methods for large-scale distributed PV integrated grid［J］.Journal of Northeast Electric Power University，2017，37（2）：82-88.

［18］ HIMOJA H，VASILADIOTIS M， RUFER A.Power interfaces and storage selection for an ultrafast EV charging station［C］//6th IET International Conference on Power Electronics, Machines and Drives. Bristol：IET，2012：1-6.

［19］严干贵，冯晓东，李军徽，等.用于松弛调峰瓶颈的储能系统容量配置方法［J］.中国电机工程学报，2012，32（28）：27-35，22.

YAN Gangui，FENG Xiaodong，LI Junhui，et al.Optimization of energy storage system capacity for relaxing peak load regulation bottlenecks ［J］.Proceedings of the CSEE，2012，32（28）：27-35，22.

［20］李建林，马会萌，田春光，等.基于区间层次分析法的电化学储能选型方案［J］.高电压技术，2016，42（9）：2707-2714.

LI Jianlin，MA Huimeng，TIAN Chunguang，et al.Selection scheme of electrochemical energy storage based on interval analytic hierarchy process method［J］.High Voltage Engineering，2016，42（9）：2707-2714.

收稿日期：2017-12-31

[1]	WANG Hanlin, LIU Yang, XU Lixiong, CHEN Xianbang, TAN Siwei. Research on Hierarchical Coordinated Optimization Model of Multi-microgrid System Considering Wind Power Consumption [J]. ELECTRIC POWER CONSTRUCTION, 2020, 41(8): 87-98.
[2]	ZHENG Huiping, ZENG Peng, LIU Xinyuan, CHENG Xueting, BO Liming, YANG Weiwei, ZHANG Yifan, CUI Yang. Active Power Layered Control Strategy Based on Error Feedforward Prediction for Multiple Temporal and Spatial Scales Wind Power Cluster [J]. ELECTRIC POWER CONSTRUCTION, 2020, 41(8): 120-128.
[3]	JIANG Dajun， WU Fubao， WANG Qiyun， ZHANG Yanjun， SUN Lixia， WU Yingjun. Robust Optimal Combined Wind-Storage Scheduling Based on Regulatory Cloud [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(7): 9-16.
[4]	FANG Chaoxiong， WU Xiaosheng， JIANG Yuewen. Research on Multi-Objective Bi-Level Optimization of Network-Storage Considering Transient Stability [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(7): 58-66.
[5]	ZHANG Haoyu， QIU Xiaoyan， ZHOU Shengrui， ZHAO Youlin， LI Linghao，ZHANG Kai. Distributed Optimal Dispatch Based on Chance Constrained Goal Programming for Multi-Area Integrated Electricity-Natural Gas Energy Systems [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(7): 82-91.
[6]	ZHANG Kai， QIU Xiaoyan， LI Linghao， ZHANG Haoyu， ZHAO Youlin， LIU Mengyi. Energy Storage Configuration Scheme Considering the Effect of Static Voltage Stability in Wind Power Systems [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(7): 110-116.
[7]	LI Jianlin， LI Yaxin，ZHOU Xichao. Summary of Research on Grid-Side Energy Storage Technology [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(6): 77-84.
[8]	CHEN Xi， XU Qingshan， YANG Yongbiao. Day-ahead Optimized Economic Dispatch of CCHP Microgrid Considering Wind Power Uncertainty [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(6): 107-113.
[9]	SU Junni，ZHANG Xin，ZHAO Junwei，ZHANG Rui，QU Minghui，YANG Yanhong. Optimal Dispatching of Integrated Electricity-Gas System Considering Demand Response and Energy Storage [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(5): 1-8.
[10]	LIN Zihan, JIANG Chenwei, CHEN Minghui, SHANG Huiyu, ZHAO Hongwei, YANG Zeng, WANG Yizheng, WEN Fushuan. Low-Carbon Economic Operation of Integrated Energy System Considering Flexible Loads [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(5): 9-18.
[11]	DU Cheng，WEI Zhenbo. Two-Stage Optimal Dispatching Model of Microgrid Based on Fuzzy Incentive Demand Response [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(5): 37-44.
[12]	LI Huaqu1，XIAO Jinsong1，SHU Zhan2，ZHANG Zheng1，YAO Liangzhong1，PENG Xiaotao1. Point-Estimation Based Method for Optimizing Both Location and Capacity of Grid-Connected Wind Farm [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(4): 109-116.
[13]	HUANG Yuanming, CHEN Qing,WEI Wei, WU Mingxing,XIE Min,DUAN Qingang,LIU Mingbo. Physical Delivery Modeling and Fast Solution Algorithms for Long and Medium-Term Spot Markets Considering Wind-Storage Participating in Direct Transactions [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(1): 55-63.
[14]	LIU Yingqi, XIE Min, WEI Wei, ZHANG Yue, LIU Mingbo. Assessment and Optimization for Power System Flexibility with High Proportion of Wind Power [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(9): 1-10.
[15]	YANG Pengpeng，ZHANG Xiuping，WANG Mingqiang，YANG Ming，ANG Fei，WANG Shibo. Optimal Operation of Wind-PV-ES Joint System Considering the Peak Regulation Capability [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(9): 124-130.